| Platinum | Shady Rest Fish & Chips |
| Gold | C-Lovers Fish & Chips |
| Silver | The Codfather's Seafood Market |
| Bronze | Surf Side California |
| Top Pick | Broken Anchor (formerly The Table Café) |
| Top Pick | Dakoda's Sports Bar & Grill |
| Top Pick | OKF Grill |
| Top Pick | Soul de Cuba Cafe |