| Platinum | Buckerfields |
| Gold | Sunshine Pet Supplies |
| Silver | 4 Paws |
| Bronze | Tail Blazers |
| Top Pick | Bone Appetit |
| Top Pick | Bosley's by Pet Valu |
| Top Pick | Buckerfield's Feeds & Pet Supplies |
| Top Pick | Homes Alive Pets |
| Top Pick | the Bone & Biscuit co. |
| Top Pick | Total Pet |