| Platinum | DunnEnzies Pizza Co. |
| Gold | Olympia Greek Taverna |
| Silver | K-Town Pizzeria |
| Bronze | Papito's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Cibo & Vines |
| Top Pick | Domino's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Hansen's Classic Pizza |
| Top Pick | Jackknife Brewing |
| Top Pick | The Curious Artistry & Alchemy Cafe |
| Top Pick | Tossing Pizzeria |
